Macronutrients for Athletes and Eating a Balanced Diet: Confronting Fat Phobia

/

As a coach, I’ve seen it time and again - athletes dialing in their training but still struggling with energy, recovery, or body composition. Often, the issue isn’t about how hard they're working, but how they’re fueling. And one common culprit? Fat phobia.

We’ve been conditioned to think dietary fat is something to avoid. But for athletes - especially endurance and power athletes - this mindset can hinder both performance and recovery. Let’s unpack the science, dismantle the myths, and rebuild a more balanced approach to nutrition.

 
Kettlebell endurance program for athletes join now $25

Build power that lasts.

Join the 4-week Kettlebell Endurance program to boost strength, stamina, and conditioning

👉 Join Program

Why Are We So Fat Phobic?

Back in the ‘80s and ‘90s, “fat-free” was the health buzzword. Supermarket shelves were lined with low-fat cookies, chips, and frozen dinners. But when manufacturers removed fat, they often replaced it with sugar and processed carbs.

The result? A rise in obesity and metabolic dysfunction - not the outcome anyone expected.

The term “fat” itself doesn’t help. Many associate it with body fat, not understanding that dietary fat and stored fat are different entities. Yes, fat is calorie-dense - offering 9 calories per gram versus 4 from protein or carbohydrates - but it's also critical for hormone production, brain health, and cellular repair.

Learn more about Best supplements for swimmers  

 

Why Are Macronutrients Important for Athletes?

Macronutrients Important for Athletes

Athletes don’t just need calories - they need quality fuel. Macronutrients (carbohydrates, protein, and fat) are the building blocks of performance:

  • Carbohydrates: the body’s primary energy source, especially during high-intensity work.

  • Protein: crucial for muscle repair and immune function.

  • Fat: essential for long-term energy, hormone health, and joint support.

Power athletes, in particular, require the right mix to support explosive movements and recovery. Name two macronutrients that are essential for muscle recovery and growth in power athletes? You guessed it: protein and fat.

 

Macronutrient Timing for Performance and Recovery

It’s not just what you eat—it’s when you eat it. Macronutrient timing plays a big role in athletic performance and recovery. Carbohydrates before a workout help replenish glycogen stores and give your body fast, usable energy. After training, your muscles are primed to absorb nutrients, so combining protein and carbs supports muscle repair and replenishment. Healthy fats, which digest more slowly, are best consumed with meals not directly around training. Understanding the timing of macronutrients for athletes can make a real difference in energy levels, recovery, and long-term results.

 

The Role of Fat in Your Body

Fat plays far more roles than most athletes realize:

  • Cell membrane structure

  • Brain composition (your brain is nearly 60% fat!)

  • Hormone production

  • Nutrient absorption (fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, K)

  • Blood sugar regulation (by slowing the absorption of carbohydrates)

In endurance athletes, fat becomes an especially efficient energy source during longer events. For athletes training multiple times per day, dietary fat also supports recovery, immune resilience, and satiety between meals.

Learn more: Post-workout nutrition 

 

Healthy Fats vs. Unhealthy Fats

All fats are not created equal. Here’s a simple breakdown:

Healthy Fats

  • Monounsaturated Fats (olive oil, avocado, nuts): Improve heart health and reduce inflammation.

  • Polyunsaturated Fats (omega-3s in fatty fish, flaxseeds, walnuts): Support brain function, joint health, and recovery.

  • Grass-fed Animal Fats: Can contain higher levels of omega-3s and CLA when responsibly sourced.

Unhealthy Fats

  • Trans Fats: Found in some processed snacks and baked goods - linked to inflammation and heart disease.

  • Excess Saturated Fat: Present in butter, fatty meats, and full-fat dairy. Not inherently harmful, but moderation and source quality matter.

 

Percentage of Macronutrients for Athletes

Macronutrient needs vary by sport, gender, training load, and goals. Here’s a general guideline for most endurance athletes:

  • Carbohydrates: 50–60%

  • Protein: 15–25%

  • Fat: 20–30%

For power athletes, the fat percentage may trend lower (20–25%) to prioritize carbs and protein for fueling and repair. But cutting fat too low can impact hormonal health and recovery - something I’ve seen derail even the most disciplined athletes.

Fat as a Hunger Regulator

One of fat’s most underrated benefits? Satiety.

A handful of almonds can keep you full for hours, whereas a fat-free granola bar often leaves you hungry soon after. That’s because dietary fat stimulates hormones like cholecystokinin (CCK) that tell your brain you’ve eaten enough.

For athletes with high caloric needs, incorporating fat can make it easier to hit intake goals without constantly eating. It also reduces cravings and energy crashes.

 

Debunking Common Fat Myths

Let’s set the record straight:

  • “Eating fat makes you fat.”
     False. Eating in a caloric surplus makes you gain weight - regardless of the macronutrient.

  • “Low-fat diets are healthier.”
     Not always. Low-fat often means high-sugar. Focus on nutrient density, not marketing labels.

  • “All saturated fat is bad.”
     Depends on the source. Natural saturated fats from whole foods can be part of a balanced diet.

 

Macronutrients vs. Micronutrients

Think of macronutrients as fuel and building materials - protein, carbs, and fat. Micronutrients (vitamins and minerals) are the fine-tuning tools. You need both for peak performance.

For athletes, deficiencies in either can lead to slower recovery, reduced endurance, or hormonal imbalance. That’s why a varied, whole-food diet is still your best tool - no supplement can fix a poor base.

Choosing the right food to eat before a swim meet can make a significant difference in your energy levels and endurance during the race.

 
Example of the balanced plate for athletes

Building a Balanced Plate for Athletes

Try this simple structure at meals:

1. Start with Healthy Fats

Avocado, olive oil, nuts, seeds, or fatty fish.

2. Add Lean Proteins

Chicken, turkey, fish, eggs, legumes, or tofu.

3. Round out with High-Fiber Carbs

Quinoa, sweet potatoes, brown rice, leafy greens, or oats.

Each plate should fuel performance, support recovery, and stabilize blood sugar.

 

Let’s Talk Fat Phobia (and the Psychology Behind It)

Fat phobia isn’t just about nutrition - it’s also psychological. Many athletes (and everyday people) link body fat with shame or failure. This has led to restrictive eating habits, disordered relationships with food, and even underperformance.

Tools like the Fat Phobia Scale measure attitudes toward weight and body composition. But instead of chasing extremes, athletes should focus on what supports their long-term performance and health.

 

Don’t Fear Fat

If you’re serious about sustainable performance and recovery, it’s time to stop fearing fat. Instead, learn how to use it as a tool:

✅ Choose whole-food sources
✅ Pair it with protein and fiber
✅ Include fat in every meal and snack
✅ Don’t fall for low-fat marketing hype

A balanced intake of macronutrients - carbs, protein, and fat - is the foundation of every athlete’s success story.

Learn more: Beet juice and athletic performance

What’s Next?

In the next article, I’ll break down the mistakes athletes make with protein and carbohydrate intake, and how to optimize both for muscle growth, energy, and blood sugar control. Stay tuned - you won’t want to miss it.

👉 Want a deeper dive into your personal nutrition? Explore personalized swim coaching that aligns your training and fueling strategy for peak results.